Over 2,000 individuals submitted feedback to the Arizona Company Fee (ACC) all through Arizona Public Companies’ (APS) fee case utility, with many expressing frustration and anger with the utility’s proposed $460 million fee hike. However no less than 16 teams that maintain ties to APS, the state’s largest investor-owned electrical utility — together with charitable contributions from the utility, board positions, and memberships — submitted feedback in assist of the speed hike, in line with an EPI evaluate of the feedback.
A whole bunch of Arizonans requested the ACC to disclaim the speed hike. The ACC had already voted in 2023 to extend residential clients’ month-to-month payments by $12 on common to accommodate excessive methane fuel costs, and clients proceed to be impacted by different excessive prices. One buyer wrote, “I’m towards the numerous fee improve that APS is proposing. I’ve lived in Arizona for over fifty years and APS has raised its charges quite a few occasions over these years … I really feel APS is NOT struggling monetary hardship and fixed fee will increase are hurting customers, particularly in these inflationary occasions.” One other mentioned, “Electrical energy is a primary want and such a rise additional hampers every day dwelling[.] Please do NOT enable this to occur[.] I’m retired and on a set revenue.”
But organizations with ties to APS, together with chambers of commerce and non-profits that work to assist underserved communities, defended the utility’s utility.
The ACC finally determined to approve a lot of the rise for APS final month – roughly $253 million, leading to clients seeing an 8% improve to their month-to-month payments. Arizona’s shopper advocate, the Residential Utility Client Workplace (RUCO), really useful a a lot smaller $84 million improve for APS. RUCO mentioned that ACC employees and APS’s suggestions had been overstated and never balanced, writing “the Firm continues to push the bounds of conventional ratemaking looking for extraordinary, utility-friendly, ratemaking mechanisms which shortchange the protections and safeguards afforded ratepayers in conventional ratemaking.”
Rooftop photo voltaic clients may even see a further cost on prime of the speed hike to their payments, and Commissioner Nick Myers – who has prioritized eliminating applications utilizing buyer cash towards renewable vitality tasks – authorised an modification to halt new participation in APS’ low-income focused “photo voltaic communities” program.
Commissioner Anna Tovar forged the one dissenting vote, stating, “We have now to steadiness between the corporate and the client and with this rule as amended I do really feel that steadiness is leaning much more in the direction of the corporate reasonably than the client.” Final yr, Tovar questioned Arizona utilities – together with APS– on charitable contributions and lobbying expenditures, following an investigation by former Commissioner Sandra Kennedy into APS’ political spending. Kennedy’s investigation revealed how APS and the APS Basis made $72,365,649 “company giving” donations to 501(c)(3) and 501(c)(4) charities between 2013 and 2021. Lots of the teams disclosed in that investigation filed letters supporting the utility’s most up-to-date fee hike.
Teams in assist of APS fee improve obtained contributions from the utility
APS has a historical past of utilizing charitable giving to affect politics and improve investor earnings, together with in earlier fee circumstances. The most recent fee case proved no totally different.
The Society of St. Vincent de Paul was the recipient of a few of APS’ largest contributions, receiving $500,000 from APS in 2021 and $56,500 in 2019. The letter of assist for the speed hike submitted by St. Vincent’s to the ACC mentions APS’ lengthy assist of the group, together with via its invoice pay help applications, ignoring the monetary burden imposed on clients going through elevated payments from the utility’s fee improve.
![](https://energyandpolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/Image-4-1-24-at-9.54 AM-1024x360.jpeg)
FIBCO Household Companies, Inc. (FIBCO), a corporation devoted to offering meals, clothes, reasonably priced housing, and healthcare to the Phoenix neighborhood, additionally cited APS’ assist “via artistic applications” providing invoice help in its letter supporting the speed request to the ACC. FIBCO obtained contributions from APS of $58,000 in 2021 and $41,000 in 2020.
The United Means of Yuma County’s letter in assist of APS said that utility representatives are “energetic members of assorted councils, boards and committees.” The group obtained contributions of $17,862 in 2021, $20,303 in 2020, and $16,671 in 2019.
Different teams that submitted letters in assist of APS’ fee improve and obtained charitable donations from the utility over a number of years included Amberly’s Place Household Advocacy Heart, which obtained $7,500 in 2020 and $8,500 in 2019, and Mary’s Meals Financial institution, which obtained $16,000 in 2021, $16,000 in 2020, and $22,000 in 2019.
EPI’s 2019 report, Strings Hooked up: How utilities use charitable giving to affect politics and improve investor earnings, examined how investor-owned utilities like APS use charitable giving to govern politics, insurance policies and regulation in methods designed to extend shareholder earnings, usually on the expense of low-income communities. A 2018 tutorial research cross-referenced the charitable giving of Fortune 500 firms towards public feedback submitted to federal companies on proposed laws and located recipients of company philanthropy usually tend to assist the businesses that give them cash attempt to get favorable regulation.
Many organizations that filed letters supporting APS’ fee improve maintain affiliations with the utility past charitable giving. The Prescott Chamber of Commerce, which obtained $52,500 in 2019 from the utility, additionally has APS Northern Division Director Frank Sanderson on its Board of Administrators. APS is listed as a “Lead Companion” on the Chamber’s web site, the best degree of sponsorship, costing $15,000 per yr.
The Arizona Chamber of Commerce and Business’s letter of assist referred to APS as an “indispensable accomplice within the growth and progress” of Arizona. This partnership contains itemizing APS as a “Champion Degree” member of the Chamber, the best company membership degree, costing the corporate $100,000 or extra yearly. APS President Ted Geisler is the Chamber’s Board of Administrators Chair-elect, and Pinnacle West – APS’ guardian firm – included the Chamber in its 2015 lobbying expense report.
The Higher Phoenix Chamber of Commerce, additionally included in Pinnacle West’s 2015 lobbying expense report, obtained $25,000 from the utility in 2020, and has APS Vice President of Exterior Affairs Stacy Derstine as a member of its Board; APS is a “Premier Member” of the Higher Phoenix Chamber.
The Globe Miami Regional Chamber of Commerce’s letter to the ACC particularly addresses the donations APS supplies the group, and Bryan Goslin, an APS challenge supervisor, is a board member on the Chamber.
Organizations affiliated with APS assist fee improve on the ACC
Many different teams affiliated with APS filed letters supporting the utility’s request to extend charges on the ACC. Gregory’s Contemporary Market, which supplies contemporary meals to underserved seniors and veterans, commented in assist of the speed case and likewise beforehand joined with APS to oppose a 2018 poll marketing campaign that may have elevated the state’s clear vitality customary. Bunney’s Inc., a development and upkeep firm that works on APS energy crops and likewise includes a photograph on its web site’s “About Us” web page with an APS backdrop, additionally submitted a remark.
The Arizona Sustainability Alliance, a recipient of $78,000 from APS in 2021, additionally has Nicholas McDonal, a enterprise techniques guide for APS, as its Board of Administrators’ Secretary. The group claims to empower Arizona residents to work towards “verdant, equitable, and sustainable communities.” Their letter of assist for APS makes no point out of the results of how a $460 million improve will affect APS clients’ month-to-month payments, nor of the brand new penalty towards rooftop photo voltaic clients. In a publication on the group’s web site, employees member Allison Boley boasts concerning the Arizona Sustainability Alliance Renewable Vitality Precedence and its partnership with Photo voltaic United Neighbors to create a photo voltaic co-op within the state. Boley states the co-op will educate Arizonans “whereas guaranteeing they’re getting the very best cope with regard to bills and rate-plans via APS.”
Buyer victory in APS fee case on commerce affiliation dues
The end result of the speed case will improve monetary burdens for APS clients. Nevertheless, the Administrative Regulation Decide (ALJ) presiding over the case included a suggestion to disallow APS’ restoration of membership dues to the electrical utility commerce affiliation, the Edison Electrical Institute (EEI). EEI has a storied historical past of utilizing ratepayer cash to fund its political actions to dam clear vitality growth and local weather motion. In a earlier APS fee case, RUCO employees said that EEI and different teams “signify the curiosity of electrical mills…donations and membership is solely voluntary, lots of that are political in nature, and is probably not essential for the supply of utility providers.”
The ACC authorised the ALJ’s suggestion, marking a possible turning level in regulatory coverage permitting price restoration of political spending for utilities.