![](https://www.powermag.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/fig1-brenmiller-tes-thermal-energy-storage.jpeg)
The significance of a dependable and resilient energy provide continues to develop, and so does the necessity to management vitality prices. That’s why extra establishments need energy techniques that help operational effectivity.
The evolving nature of vitality calls for, significantly for a lot of companies, has prompted industrial and industrial (C&I) teams to hunt progressive options for designing new or upgrading present energy techniques. One focus on this transition is on leveraging clear vitality applied sciences to reinforce vitality effectivity, promote decarbonization, and fortify vitality resiliency.
The historical past of C&I energy techniques has moved alongside a path starting with fossil fuel-burning boilers and generator units to offer warmth and steam, to applied sciences reminiscent of photo voltaic and wind, to developments reminiscent of battery vitality and thermal vitality storage.
1. Brenmiller Power’s bGen thermal vitality storage (TES) system is a patented high-temperature TES unit saved in stable state materials reminiscent of crushed rocks. It could possibly ship steam or sizzling air on demand. The know-how allows emission discount for industrial and industrial services. Courtesy: Brenmiller Power
“Fossil gas boilers are nonetheless the first technique of offering warmth and steam for industrial processes,” mentioned Doron Brenmiller, Chief Enterprise Officer at Brenmiller Power. Brenmiller informed POWER that whereas “the marketplace for fossil fuel-based thermal C&I energy techniques could also be waning, the marketplace for renewably powered thermal techniques (Determine 1) is simply beginning to take off. Thermal vitality storage delivers industrial vitality customers the identical stage of reliability that they’re used to, and at a price that’s cost-competitive with pure fuel, however with out the emissions.”
Many companies are utilizing progressive energy know-how to scale back vitality prices and improve the reliability and resiliency of their electrical energy. Learn this on-line sidebar to be taught extra about how The Sinclair Resort in Fort Price, Texas, is using vitality storage to energy its operations, changing the property’s longtime use of diesel gas.
Thermal vitality storage is simply one of many applied sciences companies are utilizing to offer their vitality wants as they set up decarbonization targets. Necessities round ESG—environmental, social, and governance—and industrial decarbonization mandates, whether or not from regulatory businesses or demanded by shareholders, are rising worldwide. That has introduced a necessity to hunt out cost-effective low-carbon options as firms overhaul present energy techniques, or construct new fashions.
“Presently prevalent applied sciences embrace photo voltaic photovoltaic (PV) techniques, vitality storage options like batteries, mixed warmth and energy (CHP) techniques, renewable pure fuel, superior metering infrastructure for higher monitoring and management, and more and more, microgrid options,” mentioned Dr. Harish Krishnamoorthy, affiliate professor {of electrical} and pc engineering on the College of Houston. “Sensible grid applied sciences, reminiscent of demand response techniques and grid-interactive buildings, are additionally gaining traction. Moreover, vitality administration techniques that make the most of superior analytics and AI [artificial intelligence] for optimization have gotten extra commonplace, enhancing effectivity in C&I settings.”
Power Effectivity and Resiliency
These C&I settings embrace faculty campuses, enterprise complexes, hospitals, resorts, and extra, the place the applied sciences referenced by Krishnamoorthy are evident. Techniques designed round vitality effectivity and resiliency, together with decreasing the carbon footprint of the enterprise, have gotten the norm.
“The district vitality sector is experiencing an thrilling interval of innovation, integration, and funding. District vitality techniques serving cities, communities, and campuses present mission-critical heating and cooling providers to related buyer buildings 24/7 year-round,” mentioned Rod Thornton, president and CEO of the Worldwide District Power Affiliation (IDEA). “By aggregating the heating/cooling wants of dozens and even a whole lot of buildings, district vitality techniques create economies of scale to allow funding in extremely environment friendly, lower-carbon applied sciences that won’t in any other case be aggressive on a person constructing foundation.”
Thornton, who spoke with POWER forward of IDEA’s latest CampusEnergy2024 convention in San Francisco, California, agreed with Brenmiller when he famous, “Many techniques in North America proceed to make the most of combustion generators with warmth restoration steam mills or extremely environment friendly boilers and enormous industrial chillers to generate steam, sizzling water, and chilled water.” Thornton agreed that new applied sciences are being deployed to advance effectivity and cut back emissions.
“Many district vitality techniques using mixed warmth and energy are additionally configured as microgrids to additional improve reliability and resilience for the mission-critical buyer, offering surplus energy and ancillary providers to the native grid,” mentioned Thornton. “Most techniques have built-in thermal vitality storage [chilled water, hot water, or ice storage] and are managed by extremely expert operations and upkeep workers utilizing very superior monitoring, management, and optimization backbones.
“Presently, we’re seeing sturdy development in giant industrial warmth pumps built-in with geo-exchange techniques or recovering warmth from native sources like wastewater in sewer mains to chop carbon emissions and seize dramatic effectivity good points,” mentioned Thornton. “As an illustration, a newly commissioned campus vitality system in New Jersey has reported a Coefficient of Efficiency (COP) of 6 whereas one other being designed in Virginia to reap knowledge heart warmth is modeling a COP of 9. Because of this for each one unit of vitality enter, six to 9 models of helpful vitality are output. These game-changing outcomes showcase one other distinct benefit of district vitality—the flexibility to retailer warmth and cooling diurnally or seasonally and to make the most of warmth for buildings that may in any other case be thrown away by way of cooling towers or just dumped down the drain.”
Decarbonization
The necessity to cut back a campus’ carbon footprint is driving most of the energy-related upgrades within the C&I sector. “Given the rising curiosity in decarbonization and vitality resilience mixed with the declining prices of unpolluted vitality know-how, the demand for C&I energy techniques is rising and broadening throughout buyer sectors,” mentioned Lou Maltezos, govt vice chairman, Central Area and Canada, at Ameresco. “Faculty campuses, enterprise parks, healthcare services, industrial services, and knowledge facilities symbolize examples of key sectors the place vitality effectivity and resiliency are paramount.”
One instance of innovation is on the College of California-Davis (UCD), the place miles of recent pipeline are distributing 1000’s of gallons of sizzling water to buildings throughout the UCD campus. The varsity, targeted on agriculture, is within the midst of a $250 million initiative known as the Huge Shift, shifting away from fossil fuels and towards carbon neutrality. The plan is designed to decarbonize the college’s present district steam heating system.
The present campus central utility plant produces steam utilizing 4 boilers that primarily burn pure fuel. The varsity additionally operates a calming water system that features thermal vitality storage. The shift to a sizzling water system means UCD will finally use electrical energy as an alternative of pure fuel to warmth the campus. Power additionally will come from the campus’ solar energy plant, and different off-site photo voltaic vitality era.
“Over the subsequent few years, the C&I energy market will seemingly witness elevated adoption of renewable vitality sources, continued developments in vitality storage applied sciences, larger integration of sensible grid options, and a shift towards decentralized vitality techniques like microgrids,” mentioned Krishnamoorthy. “Moreover, a concentrate on vitality effectivity, demand-side administration, and electrification of processes might change into extra pronounced.”
Maltezos informed POWER, “Schaeffler Aerospace Canada is an instance of the prioritization of vitality effectivity techniques to work towards decarbonization targets. Schaeffler is working with Ameresco on the set up of a brand new high-efficiency chiller and boiler system that may serve new air dealing with models at Schaeffler’s Stratford, Ontario, plant web site.” Maltezos mentioned the brand new air dealing with models are changing 5 older DX [direct expansion] cooling/fuel heating air dealing with models, “and are geared up with chilled water cooling, sizzling water heating, and variable pace followers. The undertaking may also replace the prevailing constructing automation system to combine management of the entire new high-efficiency HVAC [heating, ventilation, and air conditioning] tools.”
2. This rendering of a Wells Fargo web site in Des Moines, Iowa, reveals how the placement makes use of a mix of rooftop and ground-mounted photo voltaic to supply 30 MW of onsite energy. Courtesy: Ameresco
Maltezos famous that teams reminiscent of Wells Fargo have partnered with Ameresco to put in almost 100 photo voltaic PV arrays in retail and company areas throughout eight states, and mentioned the banking enterprise has “prioritized using on-site photo voltaic to make sure they’ve enough and clear energy assets for operations. Utilizing a mix of rooftop and floor mount techniques, the 30 MW of onsite photo voltaic at their Des Moines, Iowa, campus [Figure 2] furthers Wells Fargo’s efforts to help the renewable assets improvement in areas the place its vitality wants are the best.”
Enhancing Reliability
Kyle Julian, a regional director for C&I Gross sales at S&C Electrical, mentioned C&I operators right this moment demand ever-higher ranges of vitality reliability. “Growing reliability and resiliency calls for, mixed with the elevated energy densities required by the fashionable industrial and industrial consumer, have resulted in a serious shift. Industrial and industrial customers now have to personal the identical type of sturdy energy distribution tools and medium-voltage [5–46 kV] system designs as people who make up the spine of our electrical distribution grid.”
Julian mentioned new applied sciences provide end-users extra selection in terms of designing their vitality techniques. “Customers aren’t certain by one sort of era supply anymore,” mentioned Julian. “Medium-voltage techniques enable a number of sources of electrical energy to be built-in right into a C&I consumer’s web site, no matter origin [utility, CHP, solar]. The hunt for good energy, inexperienced energy, and onsite era as a complement to utility capability and reliability constraints might be obtained fairly merely, by way of medium-voltage microgrids and sensible switchgear. These enable for the number of the proper supply at exactly the proper time. They’ll even generate income for the proprietor—all with out sacrificing the consumer’s main mission of uptime.”
Eliminating energy outages is a key consideration for these entities that want a relentless provide of electrical energy, reminiscent of hospitals and authorities businesses. A few of these teams depend on centralized district vitality installations. Neighborhood Power, a Boston, Massachusetts–primarily based district vitality supplier, is targeted on vitality infrastructure funding. Kevin Hegerty, president and deputy CEO of Neighborhood, mentioned the applied sciences getting used to optimize vitality manufacturing and distribution for the C&I sector carry “financial, environmental, and operational advantages.” Hegerty informed POWER, “District vitality techniques provide excessive vitality effectivity, decreasing general vitality consumption and prices for industrial actual property developments. Centralized techniques guarantee dependable and uninterrupted vitality provide, minimizing downtime and disruptions for companies. District vitality can effectively serve the varied vitality wants of huge campuses, together with heating, cooling, and sizzling water, offering flexibility in assembly the precise necessities of educational and analysis services.”
Know-how upgrades additionally “enable for the mixing of renewable vitality sources, contributing to the sustainability targets of universities and life science campuses,” mentioned Hegerty. “District vitality techniques provide constant and dependable heating and cooling providers to hospitality services, guaranteeing visitor consolation and satisfaction. The centralized nature of district vitality contributes to vitality effectivity, aligning with sustainability targets typically emphasised within the hospitality trade.”
Hegerty additionally famous that these techniques help vital hundreds, reminiscent of at authorities installations, and mentioned that “shared infrastructure can result in price financial savings for presidency entities in comparison with individualized vitality techniques. District vitality [also] is well-suited for the excessive vitality calls for of arenas, effectively offering heating and cooling to accommodate giant crowds.”
“Solely 20 years in the past, giant medium-voltage C&I-owned techniques have been discovered totally on main campuses like universities, airports, and army bases,” mentioned Julian. “Since then, vital technological and computing developments have significantly expanded the segments of main C&I energy system house owners. The large energy densities required to help semiconductor chip manufacturing and knowledge facilities have led the best way, adopted by privately owned different vitality vegetation. Electrical automobile charging stations for industrial fleets and personal automobiles symbolize one other phase with large energy wants.”
Maltezos informed POWER, “Applied sciences used for industrial and industrial energy techniques right this moment vary from efficiency-related upgrades reminiscent of HVAC, lighting, constructing envelope, and controls to extra advanced techniques reminiscent of distributed vitality era by way of renewables built-in with battery vitality storage techniques and microgrid controls.”
Julian mentioned, although, there are occasions when simplicity might work higher than complexity. “Curiously sufficient, in response to the advanced new applied sciences driving the surge in reliability necessities, some customers achieved elevated reliability by decreasing the complexity of their energy techniques. As a substitute of including extra sensors and devices to traditional low-voltage tools in radial techniques, some customers have moved as much as medium voltage and invested in confirmed applied sciences organized in easy energy distribution loops. This enables backup energy feeds to proliferate all the way down to the whole facility or campus,” mentioned Julian.
Power Storage and Software program Controls
The addition of vitality storage to C&I energy techniques is permitting for extra flexibility and scalability, and is predicted to change into extra prevalent as installations evolve.
“Historically, we used to see largely gas-fired mills. Now we’re seeing extra software program choices, hydrogen gas cells, and more and more, battery storage,” mentioned John Masucci, enterprise improvement supervisor at Peak Energy, an organization targeted on vitality options for the C&I sector. “One know-how we’re seeing increasingly more is battery vitality storage techniques [BESS] which might be managed by way of software program. There are loads of benefits to BESS. When services wish to curtail their vitality use with out battery storage, they’re ramping down equipment, lighting, HVAC, or different features. This impacts manufacturing targets and occupant consolation. With a battery, they will curtail with out touching any of those. Significantly within the case of producing websites, even a millisecond of energy interruption might be catastrophic. With battery vitality storage, there’s no blip.”
Masucci informed POWER, “Most BESS prospects have a third-party controlling the batteries offsite. These operators use software program to handle the battery discharge and cost from a centralized location. They don’t want a devoted individual to handle the curtailment on the web site. All of it occurs behind the scenes. There’s no disruption to the day-to-day. All they see is financial savings on their invoice.”
The longer term development of recent C&I techniques, and the applied sciences to help upgrades, might rely upon authorities incentives that might mitigate monetary danger as enterprise operators take a look at their vitality prices. Mentioned Brenmiller: “The commercial sector may be very conservative in terms of adopting new applied sciences. Upfront funding incentives and operational incentives are key drivers to catalyze industrial gamers to put money into decarbonizing their companies. An awesome instance of how the federal government can do that is Germany; the nation’s program to create local weather safety contracts [CPCs] will make $53 billion out there to the [German] industrial sector over the subsequent 15 years. This system, which goals to counter enticing U.S. subsidies and forestall offshoring, is distinct from different climate-related funding automobiles in that it affords firms upfront the distinction in vitality transition-related working bills wanted over 15 years. This is a crucial sign for companies and offers them the funding safety they should shift to carbon-neutral operations.”
Krishnamoorthy informed POWER, “Past decarbonization, governments can help C&I energy techniques by incentivizing analysis and improvement in clear vitality applied sciences and enhancing system efficiencies, offering grants or subsidies for adopting sustainable vitality options, and facilitating regulatory frameworks that promote grid modernization and renewable vitality integration. Encouraging innovation, fostering partnerships between industries and analysis establishments, and investing in infrastructure for widespread adoption of C&I options are essential facets governments can concentrate on.”
—Darrell Proctor is a senior affiliate editor for POWER (@POWERmagazine).